Neither Michaels nor Hobby Lobby is better for every scrapbooker. Shoppers often point to Hobby Lobby for a wide, varied range of decorative paper and frequent sales, and to Michaels for organized aisles, a large sticker selection, and app or rewards offers. Which store suits you depends on what you buy, where you live, and whether you plan to use coupons or rewards.
What shoppers say each store does well
Hobby Lobby is often described as having:
- A wide and varied range of decorative papers, including eclectic and vintage-style designs
- Regular sales on paper, stamps, and embellishments
- Lower everyday prices on some basics, such as 12 x 12 albums, according to some shoppers
Michaels is often described as having:
- Aisles that are easy to browse, with scrapbooking supplies grouped together
- A large selection of stickers and sticker books
- In-house paper lines and a range of brand-name products
- Digital coupons and rewards through its app or program
These are shopper impressions, not measured comparisons, and stock varies from store to store.
Drawbacks shoppers mention
- Hobby Lobby: some shoppers find the layout crowded or hard to navigate, and checkout lines can be slow when few registers are open.
- Michaels: regular-priced items can feel expensive if you do not use a coupon or reward, and some shoppers feel the paper selection changes slowly.
Coupons and rewards
Both chains have used coupons and rewards programs over the years. Policies change often. Before you shop, check the current rules for:
- Whether the store accepts competitor coupons
- How many coupons can be used in one purchase
- Whether a reward or coupon must be used through an app
Shoppers in community forums report that these rules differ from store to store, so check your local store or the app.
Local stores often matter more than the chain
Shoppers in forum discussions often say the same chain can differ a lot from one town to the next. Inventory, prices, and staff can all vary by store. A small local shop may carry items that neither chain stocks. Online retailers and marketplaces can also fill gaps, especially for specialty papers and stamps.
For that reason, the best store is often the one closest to you that has the items you need at a price you can accept.
How to decide
- Write a short list of what you need: albums and paper, stickers, tools, or stamps.
- Compare the same three to five items in both stores or online. Note the regular price and the sale price.
- Check the current coupon or rewards rules for each store, and whether they apply to your items.
- Visit both stores if you can, and look at the paper and sticker sections in person.
- Consider a local shop for specialty items that the chains do not carry.
If one store wins on most of your list, it is probably the better choice for you. If the results are mixed, buy the basics where they are cheapest and the specialty items where they are easiest to find.
Other places to buy
- Local scrapbooking or paper shops can offer knowledgeable staff and items that large chains do not stock.
- Online retailers and marketplaces can be useful for specific papers, kits, and tools.
- Craft swaps and sales can help you find supplies you no longer need at a lower cost.
For ideas on keeping costs down no matter where you shop, see cheap scrapbooking tips. For a list of what to buy first, read the scrapbooking supplies checklist. Once you have bought a few things, how to organize scrapbook supplies can help you keep track of them, and the beginner’s guide to scrapbooking covers the first album from start to finish.